Prosecution is an effective cure for torture.
Treat ‘em harshly,
Go to town!
There’s no court
To bring us down.
Torture isn’t a good subject to fail on one’s moral report card. If you’re an individual, St. Peter is likely to take a dim view. If you’re a nation, it can cost you plenty of international prestige, besides putting hot-headed zealots yearning for revenge on your trail.
There is, of course, one effective cure for torture. It’s called prosecution. For the past decade, there’s even been a special tribunal in The Hague to try accused war crime suspects and to punish the guilty. The International Criminal Court has successfully jailed many villains, all from small countries. Big countries aren’t part of this justice system because they claim, falsely, that they can dispense justice themselves.
Take the United States. We make that claim, but somehow we’ve had trouble indicting any of our own officials. We’ll occasionally get the goods on a 2nd lieutenant or a staff sergeant, but higher-ups seem immune. Top officials are in no danger at all. Consequently, the public is. Danger of private retribution lurks where justice fears to tread.
Therefore, what America desperately needs today are some serious prosecutions to clear our moral record. With names changed to protect the suspects, in all good conscience we should investigate George W. Doe, Richard Doe, Donald Doe, Condoleezza Doe, and John Y. Doe. And from the Vietnam War days, Henry Doe. Plus, as the cover-up accomplice-in-chief in Afghanistan and the leading Libya culprit, Barack Doe.
Indeed it was Barack Doe who intoned that the country needs to “look forward, not backward.” As it turned out, the view forward wasn’t all that great either.
The political cooperation that the president counted on in recompense for letting the Republican torturers off the hook never materialized. So now he’s reluctant to look back for fear of turning into a pillar of salt, and afraid to look forward for fear of seeing his place in history as a morally doomed figure.
Luckily for tainted American leaders, they’ve got two powerful forces working in their favor. One is secrecy; the other is the media. Ever since the brilliant invention of classified documents, presidents and potentates have had a whole new crime they can level at whistleblowers — security violation. Any document that might prove embarrassing, such as evidence of torture — classify it! Then if someone reveals it, he or she can be accused of treason, and since the document is secret, officials needn’t discuss it. Just now the “trial” of Bradley Manning is our paramount example of this scurrilous technique.
The media, a president’s other priceless asset, is eager to birddog failures of sexual integrity, but not moral crimes that would diminish the nation’s stature. Thus, if a president chooses to ignore torture and other grave malefactions of state, the media isn’t about to enter that thicket.
OtherWords columnist William A. Collins is a former state representative, and a former mayor of Norwalk, Connecticut. otherwords.org
Except where otherwise noted, content on this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.
Looking for something?
New on bluetabletalk…
- The Parched Truth About American Jobs
- When Are 12-year Olds Sex Offenders?
- Obama Admin Secretly Obtains Trove of Associated Press Phone Records in “Unprecedented Intrusion”
- Failing to Heal: Hunger Strikes in Guantánamo and the Role of Medical Professionals
- US Foreign Policy on Trial in Guatemala’s Genocide Trial
- Future Politics: Fast Forward or Full Reverse
- Survival of the … Nicest? Check Out the Other Theory of Evolution
- Victory for Lake County 8th Grader as School Board Settles Gay-Straight Alliance Lawsuit After One Day
- America Wages War on Sex
- How Reinhart-Rogoff and the Austerians Produced a Sloppy Scholarly Fraud
- National Day of Reason Reaffirms the Separation of Church and State
- Breasts: A Natural and Unnatural History
- Dump the AARP
- Why Pride, Dignity and Respect Hold the Key to Ending Violence
- ACLU Statement on Miranda Rights of Boston Bombings Suspect
- Painting a Grim Picture of Art Education
- Following Push by ACLU, Lake County School Board Decides Not to Ban All Clubs
- The Case for Platonic Marriage
- CEO Pay: The French Have a Better Idea
- Fracking the First Amendment
The good man understands what is right,
the bad man understands profit.
“The greatest country, the richest country, is not that which has the most capitalists, monopolists, immense grabbings, vast fortunes, with its sad, sad soil of extreme, degrading, damning poverty, but the land in which there are the most homesteads, freeholds — where wealth does not show such contrasts high and low, where all men have enough — a modest living— and no man is made possessor beyond the sane and beautiful necessities.”
–Walt Whitman (1819-1892)
'He leaves us a lesson, which is to never accept any injustice.'
–The French President, François Hollande, speaking of Stéphane Hessel, dead at age 95.
“I believe that banking institutions are more dangerous to our liberties than standing armies. If the American people ever allow private banks to control the issue of their currency, first by inflation, then by deflation, the banks and corporations that will grow up around [the banks] will deprive the people of all property until their children wake-up homeless on the continent their fathers conquered…”
Around the web…
Above the law"The laws, Cicero wrote in the days of the Roman Republic, “are silent in time of war.” But what if the war has no end, no defined enemy, no defined territory? How can markets work if the financial behemoths are too big to fail and too big to jail? If the national security state has the power of life or death above the law, and Wall Street has the power to plunder beyond the law, in what way does this remain a nation of laws? " --Katrina van Heuvel
Waking From My Moral Coma"It is the killing, it is the permanent war, it is our deranged national priorities. It is the system we live under which requires the serial deaths of all those innocents to maintain our economic health that should appall us. We sup upon the blood and bonemeal that is the byproduct of the idea that is America, and we sleep. And we sleep." -William Rivers Pitt
- Diana on Is Your Bubbly Soap Making the Kids Sick?
- Bob HILL on Vocabulary for the New Millenium: Reconciling Independence with Interdependence
- Gerry Tatham on Alan Grayson. “Aaron Swartz, R.I.P.”
- Rabbi Stanley Howard Schwartz DD on Alan Grayson. “Aaron Swartz, R.I.P.”
- j j on SOTU 2013: Not a Game-Changing Agenda
Globalizing Torture: CIA Secret Detention and Extraordinary Rendition